Creepypodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast

This is a chill ep of CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast. Judd and Phil join me to read Jeff the Killer. Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt If you want to be prepped for future episodes, go ahead and read […]

CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast welcomes Dan Costa (Blockbuster Dropouts) and Kelly Arl to have a chat about Danny’s Story. Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt If you want to be prepped for future episodes, go ahead and read up on Why I Refuse To […]

CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast likes 7s but not 5s. Wait no, that’s The Long Face. New guests Dan Costa (Blockbuster Dropouts) and Kelly Arl join me to get paranoid. Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt If you want to be prepped for future […]

CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast is extra long this week as Will Ashton (It Ain’t Ogre ‘Til It’s Ogre) and Judd Madarang join me to talk about Netflix’s adaptation of Death Note. Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt If you want […]

It’s breakfast time this week on CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast, cuz we’re talking The Pancake Family with Lisette Voytko and Cassie Kingsbury. Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt If you want to be prepped for future episodes, go ahead and read up on […]

It’s CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast, with Lisette Voytko and Cassie Kingsbury. We talk about The Crawlspace Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt If you want to be prepped for future episodes, go ahead and read up on The Pancake Family, Dionaea House, Funnymouth, […]

CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast welcomes back Nick Wood (Stranger Still) and Kathryn Marino (Xyloart) to chat about I Am a Grown Logical Man Crying Tears of Horror, or The Story of Her Holding an Orange Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt […]

CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast returns with 1999, our topic of discussion with two returning guests — Nick Wood (Stranger Still) and Kathryn Marino (XyloArt) Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt If you want to be prepped for future episodes, go ahead […]

CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast welcomes two new guests — Dawn Gildenmeister (Beckett to the Future) and Tim Stevens (Marvel.com) — to chat about The Family Portrait. Audio is a little shaky on this one, and we lost part of the second episode of the recording session, so this will be the only one with these two, […]

Judd Madarang and Derek Sotak are back again on CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast to discuss an unexpected delight with The Sandman. Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt If you want to be prepped for future episodes, go ahead and read up […]

Some unreleased content from the Patreon. This is leftovers from the finale recording.

I thought I would have to edit out a lot of weird gaps and stuff in this episode but it actually ended up staying pretty well-synced, so you’ll have to deal with the cross-talk and interruptions instead. Judd Madarang and Derek Sotak both return to CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast and chat about SCP-2852 Support the show on […]

It’s another new episode of CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast, again with Erin Ayers and James DeBruicker of Over The Tabletop, and we discuss Harbinger Experiment. Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt If you want to be prepped for future episodes, go ahead […]

I personally think I did a bad job this episode of CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast, but my guests, Erin Ayers and James DeBruicker of Over The Tabletop, pick up the slack as we discuss Mrs. Willison’s Homemade Jam. Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music […]

Lisette Voytko and Kira White are back, with Your Body and You. BOO! It’s CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast. Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt If you want to be prepped for future episodes, go ahead and read up on Mrs. Willison’s Homemade […]

Another duo of NoSleep stories starts this week, with Does It Hurt When You Sleep?. CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast welcomes two brand-new guests to the show: Lisette Voytko and Kira White. Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt If you want to […]

Heads up: One of the videos we discuss mentions suicide, and we talk about it in the episode. Haidee Samuels and Jessie Cooper (Curiocasts Podcast Emporium) are back again, this time to chat about Kris Straub’s Local 58. The name of this show is CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast, but you knew that already. Support the show on Patreon! $1 a […]

Every story we cover is an internet story, but this one is called Internet Story. The show is CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast. The guests are Haidee Samuels and Jessie Cooper (Curiocasts Podcast Emporium) Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt If you […]

Kathryn Marino and Alex Cappello are back. Obviously. It’s in the title. The story is SCP-261. The show is CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast. Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt If you want to be prepped for future episodes, go ahead and read up on Internet […]

Kathryn Marino and Alex Cappello are back on the show with Gamer. This show? It’s CreepyPodsta: The Creepypasta Podcast. Support the show on Patreon! $1 a month gets you two bonus episodes and one short story! Theme music is by Matt Holt If you want to be prepped for future episodes, go ahead and read up on SCP-261, Dionaea House, Funnymouth, The Long Face, The Children […]